When PlunkettsGhost isn't talking about Christ, Saints & Satan.. He occasionally posts stuff about science, which is arguably when he's most a hoot (and he's literally a flat-earther).
Of course, his "debunking" of science is also religiously motivated.
Here is a thread he started on black holes -
Thread 'A physicist proves that black holes cannot exist' https://www.sarsfieldsvirtualpub.com/threads/a-physicist-proves-that-black-holes-cannot-exist.448/
The irony lost on him that he's "debunking" science with science

but anway here is my reply (to the OP)
So, let's examine both sources, both of which I didn't know anything about..
Vox Day
Vox Day is (self-)described as a "Christian nationalist", with the mainstream insisting that he is a white nationalist (which they call a "white supremacist") -
en.m.wikipedia.org
I would be perfectly happy to go with Christian nationalist or at least, that's his target audience.
The physicist
Below is a short video (7.75 minutes) of an interview with her by a well known (and knowledgeable) chap. And please note that the video is 5 years old, so I guess Vox Day was just digging up some ancient shit (that never gained any traction) to feed their (religious) audience in June 2023 -
So her thesis is that "black holes don't exist".. because Hawking radiation prevents them, which is a bit off because Hawking radiation relates to the event horizon (of a black hole).
Okay, so what is it then, what's called a black hole? The interviewer, sensibly, says - It's not a neutron star (the maximum density before the singularity) and then she says that it's about as dense (?) as a neutron star but she's calling it a "black star".
She may have thought that she was solving some problems, yes, those pesky equations do break down at the singularity (which every physicist acknowledges) and the information paradox and/or she may have thought that she could gain some notoriety but I really don't think there's much to it and I have to say, I think this thread would be better suited to the Religion forum.